VOTER ALERT
Blue Press Journal – Last week, Republican lawmakers reignited a deeply troubling campaign to pass the SAVE Act, introducing new bills in both the House and Senate. This renewed push, following the widespread rejection of last year’s attempt, represents a blatant effort to undermine the fundamental right to vote for millions of American citizens. Far from securing elections, these proposals, particularly the House’s “Make Elections Great Again Act,” are poised to create chaos, impose significant burdens on voters and election officials, and disproportionately silence marginalized communities.
At its core, the SAVE Act mandates a “show your papers” requirement for voter registration, demanding documents like passports or birth certificates. This seemingly straightforward requirement masks a harsh reality: over 21 million American citizens lack ready access to these specified documents. As analyses from organizations like the Brennan Center for Justice consistently show, millions of Americans, nearly half the population, don’t possess a passport, and many more lack easy access to a physical copy of their birth certificate. This policy would erect formidable barriers, particularly for younger voters, voters of color, and rural communities who often face greater logistical and financial hurdles in obtaining these documents. Moreover, millions of women whose married names may not align with their birth certificates or passports would be forced to navigate additional, costly bureaucratic hoops simply to exercise their constitutional right.
The financial burden on voters is undeniable. Obtaining a birth certificate or passport incurs fees, which, for many, represent an unnecessary and prohibitive cost to participate in democracy. This effectively imposes a poll tax, placing the responsibility on individual citizens to pay for documentation that, in most cases, is entirely unneeded to confirm their eligibility.
Beyond the immediate impact on voters, the SAVE Act proposals threaten to inject unprecedented chaos into election administration. The bills would place unfunded mandates on already stretched state and local election officials, compelling them to manage complex new verification processes. Officials making honest mistakes could face severe civil and even criminal penalties, risking punishment for allowing an eligible citizen to vote if the “papers” aren’t deemed sufficient. A rushed implementation, set to take effect within a year or two, would inevitably lead to widespread confusion, further hindering citizens’ ability to cast ballots.
The House’s “Make Elections Great Again Act” introduces an alarming array of additional obstacles. It demands not only proof of citizenship but also proof of residence at registration, potentially disenfranchising millions who have recently moved but haven’t updated their driver’s licenses. The bill also proposes a restrictive photo ID requirement at the polls, a standard more stringent than nearly every current state law. Student IDs, even from state universities, would be prohibited, and many tribal IDs would be rendered invalid due to the lack of an expiration date. Furthermore, it mandates voter roll purges every 30 days, disrupting the vital 90-day quiet period before elections and increasing the risk of eligible voters being mistakenly removed. The legislation also aims to eliminate universal mail voting, forcing all mail voters to apply for a ballot – a move that would upend the primary voting method in eight states and Washington, D.C.
Even the Senate’s “SAVE America Act” presents its own set of challenges, requiring voters to present documents twice – at registration and again when casting a ballot – unless states agree to routinely share their voter rolls with the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) SAVE program. This raises serious privacy concerns, especially given the Trump administration’s history of requesting state voter files under questionable pretenses. As reported by news outlets like The Washington Post, the administration faced significant pushback from dozens of states unwilling to provide sensitive voter data due to concerns about misuse, even admitting that Social Security Administration team members had turned over voter rolls to an advocacy group seeking to “find evidence of voter fraud and to overturn election results.”
Crucially, the SAVE Act offers no solution to a non-existent problem. All available evidence, including findings from the Trump administration’s own inquiries, consistently demonstrates that instances of non-citizens voting are vanishingly rare. States that have meticulously investigated their voter rolls, such as Louisiana and Utah, have repeatedly confirmed this fact. These bills are not about “election integrity”; they are about suppressing votes and sowing distrust in our democratic processes.
The League of Women Voters of the United States rightly shares “grave concerns and strong opposition” to the Make American Elections Great Again Act, stating it is “not an attempt to secure our elections, but rather an attempt to make it harder for eligible Americans to register and vote.” This legislation, in any form, is a dangerous and undemocratic proposal. Congress must reject the SAVE Act once again and protect the freedom to vote for all American citizens.
Blue Press Journal 