Tag: Barbara McQuade

  • DOJ’s New Guard: Rookie Prosecutors and the Great Legal Brain Drain

    November 19, 2026

    Within the Department of Justice (DOJ), there is a new change in hiring practices. Preston Bigley went from being a student at the Texas A&M Law School in May to working within the U.S. Attorney’s office for the Western District of Texas in August. In early October, now aged only 29, Bigley became an Assistant U.S. Attorney (AUSA) – something that would have been highly improbable a few years ago. He changed from being an incoming hire to a fully-fledged prosecutor within the government as soon as he passed the bar exam.

    Stone wall engraved with the words “Department of Justice.”

    Rookie Prosecutors

    Under this administration, many rookie prosecutors have been hired within the DOJ. These new prosecutors often have very little experience since they have only recently qualified as lawyers. This is to fill a gap caused by many experienced legal professionals leaving the DOJ.

    Brain Drain

    According to the ProPublica investigation, over 50 new AUSAs have been recruited with less than 3 years of experience. At least 20 of these individuals qualified as lawyers within the last year. Previously, the DOJ was considered to be the ‘Major Leagues’ for legal professionals, and required a minimum of 3 to 5 years of experience. However, this has changed. The DOJ no longer require a minimum of 1 year of experience.

    This has caused a huge loss of knowledge and experience in the DOJ. On average, individuals who left in this period had 13 years of experience in government. Within the first 18 months of this period, over half of individuals who left had 10 years or more of experience. This means individuals with specialist knowledge in complex corruption and money laundering have left.

    Changing Focus

    This change aligns with changes to what the DOJ is focusing on. Immigration-related charges have increased dramatically. Nationally, they have increased by 50%, however in New Mexico they have increased by 300%, and in San Diego they have increased by 125%. Meanwhile, fraud charges have decreased by 66% (in the Western District of Virginia), and drug charges have decreased by 10%. Due to the large increase in immigration-related charges, the DOJ have had to recruit attorneys from the military. Almost 100,000 Habeas Corpus applications have been submitted by immigrants in order to challenge their detention.

    Issues due to Inexperience

    Legal experts are concerned with this change. While new graduates may be hired in private firms to be trained, the government is hiring them to be leaders. “Serious crimes will go unpunished.”, Barbara McQuade, former U.S. Attorney, noted. She said that due to the inexperience of rookie prosecutors, complex corporate fraud is unlikely to be successfully prosecuted.

    Although new staff members are very excited to be fast tracked into positions, the DOJ is clearly struggling. It has been reported that prosecutors have been challenged in court to be truthful in their cases, and high profile cases against immigration protestors have fallen apart. While the DOJ insist “committed to investigating and prosecuting all types of crime,” the data suggest the DOJ is completely changing its staff, losing a massive amount of expertise built up over a century, to recruit a new group of inexperienced enforcers.