Americans Increasingly Condemn Harsh ICE Tactics, New Poll Reveals

Americans Increasingly Reject Harsh ICE Tactics, Poll Shows

Blue Press Journal – A growing majority of Americans believe U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) is using excessively harsh tactics, according to a new CBS News/YouGov poll. Conducted January 14–16, the survey of 2,523 adults found 61% now say ICE’s methods when stopping or detaining individuals are too tough. This marks a significant shift from November, when 53% held that view.

Rising Discontent Across Political Lines

The sharpest increases in criticism came from Democrats and independents, with 94% of Democrats and 68% of independents now condemning ICE’s approach — both up nine percentage points from November. Even among Republicans, the share who say ICE has been too tough rose to 19%.

This growing skepticism extends to the Trump administration’s stated deportation priorities. 56% of respondents believe the government is targeting people who are not dangerous criminals, up from 52% in November. Overall support for the administration’s deportation program has dropped from 52% to 46%.

Recent Incidents Fuel Public Concern

The shift in public opinion comes in the wake of two high-profile shootings involving ICE officers in Minneapolis. In one case, 37-year-old Renee Good was killed during a standoff with protesters. Officials claim the officer acted in self-defense, but critics say video evidence shows Good was attempting to drive away, not harm the officer. Days later, another ICE officer shot and injured a Venezuelan migrant after a traffic stop, alleging the individual attacked him during a foot chase.

A Call for Accountability

These incidents underscore concerns that ICE’s aggressive enforcement methods blur the line between lawful policing and excessive force. Civil rights advocates argue that prioritizing community safety means de-escalation, transparency, and focusing on truly dangerous individuals — not broad sweeps that ensnare non-criminal migrants.

With public opinion turning sharply against ICE’s tactics, pressure is mounting for policy reforms that protect human rights while maintaining legitimate law enforcement objectives.