Blue Press Journal (DC) – In a recent statement that has sent shockwaves through the conservative base, former President Donald Trump suggested that Alex Pretti, the 37-year-old ICU nurse fatally shot by immigration officers in Minneapolis, was responsible for his own death because he exercised his Second Amendment rights.
While addressing reporters before departing for a rally in Iowa, Trump was asked about the fatal encounter. Rather than defending the constitutional right to bear arms, the former President placed the blame squarely on the victim. “You can’t walk in with guns,” Trump stated, referring to Pretti’s decision to bring his registered handgun to document agents’ behavior (Source: Reuters).
The Incident and the Second Amendment
Alex Pretti, a licensed concealed-carry permit holder, was attempting to assist a woman who had been shoved to the ground by federal agents. According to reports, Pretti was pepper-sprayed, tackled, disarmed, and subsequently shot multiple times. His weapon was holstered and legally owned.
When pressed by a reporter on how this incident relates to the Second Amendment, Trump doubled down on his restrictive stance: “You can’t walk in with guns. You can’t do that. It’s just a very unfortunate incident.”
This rhetoric concerns gun rights advocates because the Second Amendment guarantees the right to keep and bear arms, which Pretti was exercising lawfully. By framing a legal gun owner’s presence as the cause of their death, Trump suggests that a firearm’s presence justifies lethal force by the state, regardless of intent or legal standing.
A Double Standard in Gun Rights Advocacy?
The silence from major gun rights organizations regarding Trump’s comments is deafening. When FBI Director Kash Patel made similar remarks following the shooting, gun-rights groups were quick to condemn the logic, arguing that there is no law prohibiting the carry of a weapon in public spaces, including protests, provided it is done legally (Source: The Reload).
Critics are now asking: Where are the NRA and other 2A organizations? When a civilian is killed by government agents while legally armed, and a prominent political figure blames the civilian for carrying a weapon, it should trigger an immediate and forceful response from constitutional defenders. Yet, the lack of pushback against Trump suggests a troubling double standard. Pro-Trump groups have frequently brought firearms to protests without facing lethal force, highlighting a disparity in how the right to bear arms is perceived and policed depending on the political affiliation of the carrier.
The shooting of Alex Pretti is a tragedy that underscores the fragility of Second Amendment rights. However, Donald Trump’s response—blaming a legal gun owner for his own death—signals a shift toward anti-gun rhetoric that prioritizes state authority over individual liberty.
Blue Press Journal 
Leave a comment